Udayavni Special

Can excessive media reporting hinder justice? HC asks Centre


Team Udayavani, Oct 29, 2020, 3:41 PM IST

Mumbai: The Bombay High Court on Thursday asked the Union government to clarify whether ‘excessive’ reportage by the press on an ongoing investigation amounted to interference in the administration of justice under the Contempt of Courts Act.

A bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice G S Kulkarni asked the government to state by November 6 if such reportage adversely affects the probe and subsequent trial, and if the court should lay guidelines on media reporting.

“If there is excessive reporting, that can put an accused on guard, and he may resort to destroying evidence or absconding. Or if that person is actually innocent, the excessive media reporting can damage his reputation,” it said.

“We would not like the media to cross its boundaries and we would also like to be within our boundaries,” the court said and asked the state if such reportage would amount to interference and if the government thought the HC had the jurisdiction to frame guidelines.

“Whether excessive reporting by media in an ongoing investigation amounts to interference in the administration of justice under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act and should we lay guidelines? This is the issue before us,” HC said.

It also asked the government’s counsel, Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Anil Singh, to consider scenarios where such reportage on an ongoing probe, where a charge sheet was yet to be filed, influenced the investigating officer or resulted in a witness being threatened.

It asked if the court must step in and formulate guidelines to regulate the press to avoid such scenarios.

“If media identifies that a person is a very vital witness, he could be won over, threatened, or he could be even physically harmed so that he does not give evidence,” it said.

On the possibility of the press influencing an investigating officer, the HC said, “Think of a police officer. Can anyone guarantee that he will not be influenced?”

“He may be following a particular track. Media says no no this must be the track. He loses track and rounds up an innocent person,” it said.

“Or, if the officer is competent and does not get influenced, then the media starts maligning him. Is this welcome in a society governed by rule of law?” the HC asked.

The court was hearing final arguments on a bunch of public interest litigations seeking that the media trial in the probe into actor Sushant Singh Rajput’s death be stopped.

The pleas have been filed by some activists and retired police officers.

On the previous hearings, the HC heard the petitioners, private TV news channels, and the National Broadcasters Standards Authority (NBSA) on the need for a regulatory mechanism for the electronic media.

The TV channels and the NBSA argued in favour of a self-regulatory mechanism and said the state must not be given any control over their content.

On Thursday, the HC said it had expected the government to address the court on the queries raised above.

It directed ASG Singh to file his written submission and address the court on November 6 on all the questions raised by the bench.

The court said the media often defended such reportage by saying it constituted investigative journalism.

However, investigative journalism meant “to lay bare the truth,” it said.

“Is there any law which says that whatever an investigation agency collected as evidence should be laid before the public? Where is the obligation for the investigating officer to disclose evidence?” the HC asked.

“How does the postmortem report come to the media unless of course it is disclosed? Should we lay down guidelines on these aspects?” the court sought to know.

The HC also said if the press had access to information that could aid a probe, then it should give such information to police under Section 38 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Petrol price crosses Rs 82-mark, diesel above Rs 72 a litre

CM and central leadership will take final call on Cabinet expansion: DyCM in M’luru

Guj: Modi reviews vaccine development at Zydus Cadila facility

UP Guv gives assent to ordinance against forcible religious conversions

Farmers gathered at Singhu, Tikri border points refuse to head to north Delhi protest site

Covid-19 caseload in India climbs to over 93.5 lakh

US sanctions Russian, Chinese cos for supporting Iranian missile programme



Related Articles More

Illegal coal trade: CBI raids 40 places in 3 states

Guj: Modi reviews vaccine development at Zydus Cadila facility

UP Guv gives assent to ordinance against forcible religious conversions

Farmers gathered at Singhu, Tikri border points refuse to head to north Delhi protest site

Covid-19 caseload in India climbs to over 93.5 lakh

MUST WATCH

Assorted flowers, fruits, and vegetables are grown in the terrace garden

Celebrating 25 Years of Laveena Masala | Since 1996 | Udayavani

Mangalore: Lashkar militants pro wall writing on on Circuit House Road | Udayavani

Madhavashankara name for Mangalore airport: Shri Sugunendra Tirtha Swamiji

Centuries-old Tuluva ritual of ‘Bhoomipuje Gaddekori’ still performed at Palthadi Village in Puttur

Latest Additions

Iran’s top nuke scientist assassinated after gunfight with security team

Cosmos Malabaricus highlighting Kerala’s history based on 17th-century Dutch records to be launched

Illegal coal trade: CBI raids 40 places in 3 states

Modernization of police dept: State govt to sanction Rs 100 cr

Petrol price crosses Rs 82-mark, diesel above Rs 72 a litre

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.