Udayavni Special

Jinnah’s idea winning in India: Shashi Tharoor on CAA


PTI, Jan 27, 2020, 9:54 AM IST

Jaipur: Senior Congress leader Shashi Tharoor has said if the CAA leads to the implementation of the NPR and the NRC, it would be a complete victory for Pakistan’s founding father Muhammad Ali Jinnah.

He said Jinnah’s idea of a country was already winning in India with the contentious Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) coming into effect, but asserted that there was still a choice available.

“I would not say Jinnah has completely won, but I would say Jinnah is winning. There is still a choice available to the nation between Jinnah’s idea of a country and Gandhiji’s idea of a country,” he said on the sidelines of the Jaipur Literature Festival on Sunday.

The CAA came into force in India in December amid protests across the country and around the world.

The MP from Thiruvananthapuram said the amended Citizenship Act took Jinnah’s logic by declaring that religion shall be the basis of nationhood, reaffirming that Gandhi’s idea is that all religions are equal.

“The CAA is, if you are talking Tennis, you would say one set up or big first set lead for Jinnah. But the next step would be if the CAA would lead to the National Population Register (NPR) and the National Register of Citizens (NRC). If that happens, then you would consider that Jinnah’s victory is complete,” he said.

The CAA seeks to grant citizenship to migrants belonging to Hindu, Sikh, Buddhist, Christian, Jain and Parsi communities who came to India from Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan on or before December 31, 2014.

On the BJP’s defence that the NPR was carried out during the UPA regime, Tharoor said the Congress government had utilised a decision of the NDA government led by former prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee.

“It never asked where were your parents born. It never authorised the enumerators to note on the margin ‘dubious citizenship’, a term used in the NPR rules crafted by this government. That is purely BJP’s invention,” he said.

If we go around this country authorising people to interview all the citizens, or identify some who have ‘dubious citizenship’, you can be pretty sure which Indians are going to be found on the ‘dubious citizenship’, he said.

“That will principally be one community that is not mentioned in the CAA. And if that happens, then it is indeed Jinnah’s victory.

“From wherever he is, he can point to this place and say, ‘see I was right in the 1940. We are separate nations and Muslims deserved their own country because Hindus cannot be just’,” Tharoor said.

Speaking about the Delhi election, the three-time MP said the maximum development in the national capital happened under the Congress government.

“What Sheila Dikshit did in her 15 years as Chief Minister of Delhi, no other leader could do it before or after her,” he said.

Top News

Kerala risks sliding into community transmission: Pinaryi Vijayan

Karnataka concerned about recent spike in COVID-19 cases, but well prepared to handle: Govt

In a first, Twitter adds fact-check warnings to Trump tweets

Karnataka: Farmers team up with Flipkart to home deliver mangoes

Amid border standoff with China, PM Modi holds meeting with NSA, CDS and 3 Service Chiefs

Truecaller records of 4.75 cr Indians on sale for Rs 75,000

SC takes suo motu cognizance of miseries of migrant labourers

Related Articles More

Kerala risks sliding into community transmission: Pinaryi Vijayan

COVID-19 crisis Rahul Gandhi speaks to experts in healthcare social sciences

India women footballer Indumathi Kathiresan busy enforcing lockdown in police uniform

Amid border standoff with China, PM Modi holds meeting with NSA, CDS and 3 Service Chiefs

Truecaller records of 4.75 cr Indians on sale for Rs 75,000

MUST WATCH

Tragedy and chaos: Former MIA director recalls Mangalore Air Crash

Lockdown relaxation: Long queues outside liquor stores in Mangaluru

Indian Coast Guard thank Covid-19 warriors

#WeFeed – Feeding stray animals during lockdown!

Mysuru-origin doctor honoured with parade for her service in treating COVID-19 patients in US

Latest Additions

Kerala risks sliding into community transmission: Pinaryi Vijayan

COVID-19 crisis Rahul Gandhi speaks to experts in healthcare social sciences

West Indies cricketers resume training after COVID-19 hiatus

India women footballer Indumathi Kathiresan busy enforcing lockdown in police uniform

Karnataka concerned about recent spike in COVID-19 cases, but well prepared to handle: Govt

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.