Udayavni Special

SC to examine if a person in power is accountable for speech on rape victim


Team Udayavani, Mar 30, 2017, 9:07 AM IST

New Delhi: The Supreme Court on Wednesday said that it will examine whether a person in power can be held accountable for making a statement in public about a rape victim who has the fundamental right of protection of life and personal liberty.

A bench of Justices Dipak Misra and A M Khanwilkar said that it will have to see whether the fundamental right of freedom of speech and expression will be governed under reasonable restriction of decency or morality or other preferred fundamental rights will also have impact on it.

“Both Article 19 (freedom of speech and expression) and Article 21 (protection of life and personal liberty) are preferred rights.

“We need to see whether freedom of speech and expression which is not absolute can be governed only by reasonable restriction provided under Article 19 (2) or Article 21, will also have impact on it,” the bench said.

It said, “The core issue, as is projected before us, is whether the right conferred under Article 19(1)(a) is to be controlled singularly by the language employed under Article 19(2) or also the other fundamental right, that is right under Article 21 would have any impact on it.”

The bench, while giving an example, said that if a minister or government servant like a DGP in exercise of freedom of speech and expression makes a statement that alleged incident of rape is false or an outcome of political controversy then can he be held accountable.

It further said that the said statement of the minister or government servant may give a direction to the probe in the case and impact the fundamental right of the rape victim under Article 21 of Constitution.

The court was hearing a plea filed by a man whose wife and daughter were gangraped in July last on a highway near Bulandshahr, seeking transfer of the case to Delhi, besides lodging of an FIR against former Uttar Pradesh minister Azam Khan for terming the alleged incident as an outcome of political controversy.

The top court had earlier said it would deliberate upon the questions framed by it on the freedom of speech and expression and probable impact of statements of those holding high offices on free and fair probe in heinous cases including rape and molestation.

Attorney General Mukul Rohatgi said reasonable restrictions are already provided for Article 19(1)(a) in 19 (2) in the bracket of decency or morality.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Don’t vote for JD(S): Siddaramaiah to minority community

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Pakistan Navy claims it blocked Indian submarine from entering into country’s waters

K’taka: Six achievers chosen for Sri Maharishi Valmiki Awards 2021

PM Modi afraid of speaking on China: Owaisi

Maharashtra: Theatres to reopen from October 22; restaurants, eateries can function till midnight

IndiGo cautions candidates against fake job offers

Related Articles More

Man’s kidney removed during stone operation; Hosp ordered to pay Rs 11.23 lakh compensation

Increasing activities by China in depth areas of eastern sector: Eastern Army Commander

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Over 300 people rescued from flood-affected Uttarakhand: NDRF

Amit Shah flags off Modi Vans for Kaushambi in UP

MUST WATCH

INDIAN ARMY RESCUES THE CIVILIANS STUCK IN NAINITAL FLOODS

UDAYAVANI NEWS BULLETIN|19/10/2021

Specialties Of Kapila MalnadGidda cow Breed

THE FOREST DEPARTMENT PROCEDURE ON DEEMED FORESTS

Chintamani Crime news


Latest Additions

Man’s kidney removed during stone operation; Hosp ordered to pay Rs 11.23 lakh compensation

Increasing activities by China in depth areas of eastern sector: Eastern Army Commander

Don’t vote for JD(S): Siddaramaiah to minority community

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Over 300 people rescued from flood-affected Uttarakhand: NDRF

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.