Udayavni Special

Why should TV news not be regulated by govt, asks HC


Team Udayavani, Sep 10, 2020, 3:15 PM IST

Image for representation

Mumbai: The Bombay High Court on Thursday, September 10 said it was surprising to know that the government had no control over the electronic media and asked why television news should not be regulated by the state.

The observation was made by a bench of Chief Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice G S Kulkarni while hearing a bunch of petitions that sought various reliefs related to the case of the death of actor Sushant Singh Rajput, including a direction to restrain the press in its coverage of the case.

The bench impleaded the Union Ministry of Information and Broadcasting as a party in the matters.

It also directed the ministry to file a reply in court indicating the extent of state control that is exercised in respect of telecasting news, particularly such news that “may have serious ramifications”.

The bench also made the Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) and the Enforcement Directorate (ED), the central agencies that are currently probing issues related to the case, as parties.

This, after one of the petitioners alleged that the agencies were “leaking” probe related information to the press and the public.

The bench, however, refused to implead actor Rhea Chakraborty as a respondent in the case.

“We do not see any reason to implead the proposed respondent number 12 (Chakroborty), an accused who is presently in judicial custody,” it said.

The petitions, filed by activists, and eight retired senior police officers, allege, among other things that several TV channels were running a parallel probe into the case, and that they were running a malicious campaign against the Mumbai police through their current reportage in the case.

On September 3, another bench had heard the same pleas and had passed an order urging the press to show restraint while covering the developments of Sushant Singh Rajput’s death case.

On Thursday, senior advocate Milind Sathe, who appeared for the former police officials, told the bench that despite the order, TV channels were continuing with their slander against the Mumbai police.

Sathe submitted transcripts from news broadcasts whereby, channels had insinuated that the Mumbai police had been assisting or shielding the accused, and the “drug mafia”. CJ Datta told advocate Sathe that he shouldn’t be bothered by what a news anchor was saying.

He, however, added that the court hoped and trusted that “the spirit of the order dated September 3” would be kept in mind by TV news channels.

The Union government, meanwhile, pointed out that the petitioners should have approached the Press Council of India, a statutory body which regulates the print media, and the News Broadcasting Standards Authority (NBSA) with its grievances against the TV news channels.

At this, the bench noted that the NBSA wasn’t a statutory body.

“We are surprised that the state has no control over the electronic media. Why should it (TV news) not be regulated in case they may have serious ramifications,” the bench said.

It directed all parties to file their replies, rejoinders etc within the next two weeks, adding that while the pleas remained pending, the NBSA was free to act upon any complaints received so far against such news.

Top News

SP Balasubrahmanyam extremely critical: Hospital

CBI, and not NCB, should probe drugs case: Rhea to HC

Second wave of COVID-19 hits its peak in Delhi, number of cases to decline in coming days: Kejriwal

Featured on TIME’s list, Bilkis says would have been happier if demand was met

Dean Jones’ sudden death leaves cricketing world in shock

Rail roko agitation to severely affect movement of essential items, foodgrains: rlys

Oppn moves no-confidence motion against BSY govt




Related Articles More

Four people killed in building collapse in Punjab town

CBI, and not NCB, should probe drugs case: Rhea to HC

Second wave of COVID-19 hits its peak in Delhi, number of cases to decline in coming days: Kejriwal

Featured on TIME’s list, Bilkis says would have been happier if demand was met

Rail roko agitation to severely affect movement of essential items, foodgrains: rlys

MUST WATCH

Young man from Mangaluru builds mini tipper

Udupi Krishna temple to be open for public from September 28 | Udayavani

‘Road Politics in Times of Pandemic’: St Aloysius Institution reacts to road renaming

Mangaluru Light House Hill Road renamed as Mulki Sunder Ram Shetty Road

Soraba : District Excise Department seized Millions worth of Marijuana | Udayavani

Latest Additions

Southern Railway announces operating two daily specials from Chennai to TVM and Mangaluru from Sep 27

Who is Flight Lt Shivangi Singh, set to be the first woman pilot to fly Rafale?

Four people killed in building collapse in Punjab town

Bengaluru violence: NIA conducts searches at 30 places, arrests key conspirator

SP Balasubrahmanyam extremely critical: Hospital

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.