HC dismisses Kochhar’s plea against termination of employment


Team Udayavani, Mar 5, 2020, 4:42 PM IST

Mumbai: The Bombay High Court on Thursday dismissed a petition filed by Chanda Kochhar against her termination as managing director and CEO of the ICICI Bank, noting the dispute arises from a contract of personal service.

A division bench of Justices N M Jamdar and M S Karnik accepted the bank’s contention that Kochhar’s petition was not maintainable as the dispute was contractual and concerns a private body.

“The termination of the petitioner is in the realm of contractual relationship,” the court said in its order.

Courts cannot exercise their writ jurisdiction when employment in a private entity is regulated by contracts, it further said.

“Contractual duties are enforceable as matters of private law by ordinary contractual remedies such as damages, injunction, specific performance and declaration,” the high court said.

The bench in its order noted that even if an institution is performing a public duty and is amenable to writ jurisdiction, all its decisions would not be subject to judicial review.

“If the private body is discharging a public function and the denial of any right is in connection with the public duty imposed on such body, the public law remedy can be enforced,” the court said.

It took note of the fact that ICICI was a private bank governed by a board of directors and did not receive any funds from the government.

The ICICI Bank’s counsel Darius Khambata earlier argued that a judicial review cannot be incurred under Article 226 of the Constitution, which empowers high courts to issue directions, orders or writs in such a matter.

The bank sought dismissal of Kochhar’s petition.

Kochhar was terminated from the ICICI Bank months after she voluntarily left the second largest private sector lender.

The high-profile former banker moved the high court on November 30, 2019, challenging “termination” of her employment by the ICICI Bank.

She contended that the bank also denied her remuneration and clawed back all the bonuses and stock options between April 2009 and March 2018, for her alleged role in granting out of turn loans worth Rs 3,250 crore to the Videocon Group which benefitted her husband Deepak Kochhar.

Kochhar’s counsel Vikram Nankani earlier argued that her termination came months after the bank approved her voluntary resignation on October 5, 2018 and therefore, the termination is “illegal, untenable and unsustainable in law”.

The ICICI Bank then filed an affidavit, contending the reliefs in the petition are not maintainable and it deserves to be dismissed as ICICI is a private bank and is administered under the Companies Act, not the state or its agency.

Khambata argued that ICICI was a private banking company and Kochhar’s petition seeks to contest what are purely private contractual terms.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

SC to hear Centre’s plea against Tripura HC order on security cover to Ambanis

Alia Bhatt, Ranbir Kapoor expecting first child

Shiradi ghat to be closed for four months?

Kunigal: Woman raped while grazing cattle; Accused arrested

Markets maintain winning run to 3rd day amid firm trends in global markets

Bengaluru: IKEA sees ‘traffic jam’ of people, 3-hour wait to enter store

Monkeypox: 3 things we need to know next about how it’s mutating & spreading


Related Articles More

Markets maintain winning run to 3rd day amid firm trends in global markets

EXPLAINER: What’s the impact of a Russian debt default?

28 pc GST likely on casinos, online gaming, horse races on gross revenue

FinMin asks banks to explore fintech partnership, co-lending opportunities

FPIs’ exodus continues; pull out Rs 46,000 cr from Indian equities in Jun so far

MUST WATCH

selfie craze : Traffic Jam at Charmadi

NEWS BULLETIN 26-06-2022

National Lok Adalat Case Solved at Udupi

NEWS BULLETIN JUNE 25-06-2022

Road Mishap at Sakaleshpur : school teacher end his life


Latest Additions

K’taka doctor on Himalayan expedition incommunicado since June 20

Maha political crisis: CM hands over portfolios of 9 rebel ministers to other ministers

Delhi Congress holds protest against Agnipath scheme

Yashwant Sinha files nomination for prez poll

Didn’t want to risk playing Gaikwad as he had a calf niggle: Pandya

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.