Udayavni Special

Nirav Modi extradition: UK court finds no evidence of political influence

PTI, Feb 25, 2021, 8:36 PM IST

London: The UK judge who handed down his judgment on Thursday in favour of the extradition of Nirav Modi to face charges of fraud and money laundering in India said he had found no evidence of adverse political influence in the case, as claimed by the diamond merchant’s legal team.

In support of their claims, Modi”s lawyers had deposed retired Supreme Court judge Markandey Katju – of whom District Judge Samuel Goozee was highly critical and dubbed the evidence as “less than objective and reliable”.

“Albeit, some political commentary could be described as ill-advised, there is nothing in the volumes of media, broadcasting or social media links that have been referred to me in the voluminous defence bundles that gives any indication that politicians are trying to influence the outcome of any trial, let alone NDM’s (Nirav Deepak Modi) trial or that the trial process itself would be susceptible to such influence,” Justice Goozee notes.

“I reject any submission that the GOI (government of India) have deliberately engineered a media onslaught. I attach little weight to Justice Katju’s expert opinion,” he said.

With reference to Katju’s testimony via videolink last year, Justice Goozee felt it appeared tinged with resentment towards former senior judicial colleagues and described parts of it as “astonishing, inappropriate and grossly insensitive comparisons”.

“It had hallmarks of an outspoken critic with his own personal agenda. I found his evidence and behaviour in engaging the media the day before giving evidence to be questionable for someone who served the Indian judiciary at such a high level appointed to guard and protect the rule of law,” Goozee notes in his ruling.

Despite being critical of the “trial by media” and its impact on the Modi case, the Westminster Magistrates” Court judge expressed surprise that Katju, who was a Supreme Court judge from 2006 to 2011, took the “astonishing decision” to brief journalists in relation to the evidence he was giving in the UK proceedings, “creating his own media storm and adding to the heightened media interest to date”.

Goozee was also critical of former High Court judge Abhay Thipsay”s evidence, another defence witness who had been deposed as an expert on how the case would play out in the Indian courts.

The UK judge noted that Thipsay had aligned himself with a political party (Congress) on his retirement and received adverse commentary in the media as a result, but that he also engaged with and courted the media himself.

“Overall, these factors have the effect, in my assessment, of nullifying any weight I would have attached to his evidence,” the ruling notes.

The UK judge, who found a prima facie case of fraud and money laundering against Modi in the Punjab National Bank (PNB) scam case, further declared that there was no evidence which allowed him to find that if extradited the jeweller would be at “real risk of suffering a flagrant denial of justice” as pleaded by his lawyers.

He accepted that the accused being a high-profile businessman who made a huge success of the Nirav Modi brand in India and worldwide was the target of “sensationalised” media reporting, but pointed out that such reporting is not unfamiliar to the courts even in the UK.

“India is governed by its written constitution which has at its core the fundamental principle of the independence of the judiciary by virtue of the separation of powers between judiciary, the executive and the legislature. There is no cogent or reliable evidence that the judiciary in India are no longer independent, or capable of managing a fair trial even where it is a high-profile fraud with significant media interest,” the ruling concludes.

The judgment will now go to UK Home Secretary Priti Patel, who has two months to order extradition on the basis of the court”s findings.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Three arrested for hoarding, black-marketing Remdesivir, vital for COVID treatment

HC extends interim bail of injured murder convict in view of COVID-19 pandemic

Pregnant, lactating mothers exempted from coming to office: M’luru Compol

Anupama Puchimada, the first ever International Woman Hockey referee from India dies of Covid-19

Government plans to have large fleet of Hydrogen-run buses in India

Sudhakar says govt will provide Remdesivir to 33 hospitals

Mangaluru: Gold worth Rs 24.4 lakh seized by Customs at MIA

Related Articles More

US nurse charged for allegedly threatening to kill Vice-President Kamala Harris

Alexei Navalny’s doctor says the Vladimir Putin critic ‘could die at any moment’

Founder of Adobe and developer of PDFs dies at age 81

Prince Philip laid to rest in Royal Vault at Windsor Castle

Queen sits alone at funeral for Prince Philip to set example


George Kadiyali | Can We Grow More Food on Less Land?

Udayavani 17-April-2021 News Bulletin

The fear of Covid 2nd Wave!!

Congress Karyakartas accuses police

Success story of a retired teacher in Betel Leaf Farming | Betel Leaf Cultivation

Latest Additions

Can’t do anything that’s not personal: Alfonso Cuaron on his cinema and ‘The Disciple’

Less than 100 ICU beds vacant in Delhi hospitals, situation worsening every moment: CM Kejriwal

Religious events: Kota Poojary writes to CM BS Yediyurappa for relaxations

Three arrested for hoarding, black-marketing Remdesivir, vital for COVID treatment

HC extends interim bail of injured murder convict in view of COVID-19 pandemic

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.