Udayavni Special

SC upholds life term for 3 for killing Gujarat Shiv Sena leader


Team Udayavani, Mar 27, 2017, 12:36 PM IST

New Delhi: The Supreme Court has upheld the life term awarded to three persons for killing a Shiv Sena leader in Gujarat whose younger brother had married a woman from a minority community.

A bench of Justices P C Ghose and Ashok Bhushan said the homicidal death has been proven beyond all reasonable doubt with the recovery of the weapon which was a “sharp knife” and the high court order did not call for any interference.

“The fact that the accused had been identified and recovery made from accused no.1 has left no room for doubt that all the appellants were involved in the commission of the murder with the common object to do away the deceased…

“We are of the view that the present appeal is devoid of merits and we, therefore, do not find any reason to interfere with the order of the high court. Hence, the appeal is dismissed,” the bench said.

On July 4, 2009, five persons had barged into the house of Rameshbhai Prajapti, a taluka president of Shiv Sena when he was sleeping with his wife and children, and had assaulted him with the knife inflicting grievous injuries in his neck.

The whole incident was witnessed by Prajapati’s wife as she woke up after hearing the noise and saw the men escape from the spot.

The trial court in 2010 convicted four persons including Soyebbhai Yusufbhai Bharania who had led the group and awarded them life sentence while holding them guilty for murder and rioting. It has said that the younger brother of the victim had got married to a woman hailing from a particular community despite protest by the men.

The trial court, however, had given benefit of doubt to Umarbhai, one of the five men, and acquitted him.

The four convicts had challenged the verdict of the trial court in the Gujarat High Court which had upheld the life sentence given to three persons and acquitted one of them.

The apex court, while dismissing the appeals, said that in furtherance of the common intention to kill Prajapati, the men had entered his house and they were seen by his wife.

It said that since out of the five men, two were acquitted by the trial court and the high court respectively, the charge of unlawful assembly does not meet the pre-requisite condition of a minimum of five persons.

“In our view, albeit the murder is proved but the ingredients of the unlawful assembly remained elusive, as pre-requisite condition for an unlawful assembly i.e., minimum five persons, has not been met. Nevertheless, the common object has been proved by the prosecution,” it said.

Udayavani is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest news.

Top News

Don’t vote for JD(S): Siddaramaiah to minority community

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Pakistan Navy claims it blocked Indian submarine from entering into country’s waters

K’taka: Six achievers chosen for Sri Maharishi Valmiki Awards 2021

PM Modi afraid of speaking on China: Owaisi

Maharashtra: Theatres to reopen from October 22; restaurants, eateries can function till midnight

IndiGo cautions candidates against fake job offers

Related Articles More

Man’s kidney removed during stone operation; Hosp ordered to pay Rs 11.23 lakh compensation

Increasing activities by China in depth areas of eastern sector: Eastern Army Commander

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Over 300 people rescued from flood-affected Uttarakhand: NDRF

Amit Shah flags off Modi Vans for Kaushambi in UP

MUST WATCH

INDIAN ARMY RESCUES THE CIVILIANS STUCK IN NAINITAL FLOODS

UDAYAVANI NEWS BULLETIN|19/10/2021

Specialties Of Kapila MalnadGidda cow Breed

THE FOREST DEPARTMENT PROCEDURE ON DEEMED FORESTS

Chintamani Crime news


Latest Additions

Man’s kidney removed during stone operation; Hosp ordered to pay Rs 11.23 lakh compensation

Increasing activities by China in depth areas of eastern sector: Eastern Army Commander

Don’t vote for JD(S): Siddaramaiah to minority community

Opposition flays Kerala govt’s flood management

Over 300 people rescued from flood-affected Uttarakhand: NDRF

Thanks for visiting Udayavani

You seem to have an Ad Blocker on.
To continue reading, please turn it off or whitelist Udayavani.